‘Tis the season and POTD has Black Friday Deals
Go to https://www.puntoftheday.com/BF3 for 50% off a 3 month subscription
Go to https://www.puntoftheday.com/BF12 for 33% off an annual subscription
Firstly, apologies for slacking on Week in Review posts and Sunday Special posts. Without getting too much into my personal life, my newborn has begun waking up in the middle of the night and my days have been full of struggling to accomplish basic tasks like brushing my teeth. I have been slacking, but I hope to get back to a weekly Week in Review posting schedule. If you have a Sunday Special to submit, my inbox is open. If you have previously sent me a Sunday Special, feel free to bump it— there is a good chance I have forgotten about it.
Earlier this week, David Lappin posted a video from a viral reddit thread from the Triton One High Roller FT with the caption “Dodgy looking dealing.” The video showed the dealer flash the ace of hearts on the bottom of the deck, then miss the bottom of the deck when riffling the cards, then the dealer prepares the deck, reaches for her cut card, and the video ends before she cuts the deck and deals the cards. The hand that follows is a wild one and I’ll be giving it the full POTD treatment shortly, but I’ll transcribe the hand history below and link to it here, before I delve into the controversy.
It folds to chip leader Alex Zubov (25.5M/64bbs) in the SB who raises to 1.2M with Th5h, Danilo Velasevic (11M/28bbs) calls in the BB with Qs8d. On Qh8c6s9h3s Alex bets 900k and is called. Bets 2.3M and is called and shoves the river for 6.6M and get’s Danilo to fold his two pair.
The viral clip features bad dealing, but it is not dodgy dealing. Dodgy implies something untoward is happening, and I think this is a good spot to invoke Hanlon’s Razor: “Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity,” or in this case incompetence. Ideally, a dealer will never miss the bottom of the deck when shuffling; however, nobody is perfect and mistakes will happen. What’s important is that once she misses the deck— something any experienced dealer will feel— she corrects her mistake and reshuffles. This is at a final table with a fixed number of hands per level, so it’s not even like she is wasting the clock and affecting the game play in any way by reshuffling.
I’ve heard stories of players trying to spot cards when dealers pitch too high or otherwise try to gain information that sloppy dealers give away when they don’t shuffle properly or expose cards, so it is important that mistakes like this never happen. My understanding is that her flashing the Ah on the bottom of the deck is not a big deal. It’s impossible to keep a permanent cut card on the bottom of the deck, lest it get shuffled into the deck. Therefore, before the dealer cuts the deck, there is always a chance the bottom card will be exposed to someone. If she held the deck facing her instead of facing away from her, she’d expose the bottom card to the 1 and 9 seat, and if she were a mechanic, she’d know what card was on the bottom of the deck, which would aid bottom-dealing. There is always a chance someone will see the bottom card, which is why it’s important the whole deck is shuffled and the deck is cut in the first place.
Triton prides itself on having excellent dealers, especially at final tables, and their staff are almost universally praised, so when they make a misstep I think it is fair to criticize them. This is one of the few times I’ve ever seen a Triton dealer publicly criticized, and I do not believe this will become commonplace because their dealers are excellent. Criticizing a mistake is fair; however, I also think doing slow-motion forensic video analysis of dealers and weighing every mistake they make in terms of what it might say about their integrity is nasty business to get into. That has not happened yet, but I really hope this little scandal is a one-off, both because I hope the quality of dealing is flawless, and because I don’t want micro-analyzing dealers to become a cottage industry on poker reddit or social media.
So why am I so confident this is bad dealing and not “dodgy” dealing? For starters, dealers who cheat are likely very gifted mechanics and would not look so amateurish cheating. Second and most importantly, we have a hole-cards-up final-table stream to look at. If you think there was cheating going on at the FT, then you need to make an inference beyond “the dealing in this hand looks sloppy.” Who is this dealer trying to cheat? Who is she trying to help? What evidence from the hands that were played bolsters the case that she was trying to help someone? No one has really provided any evidence because there is not any. The actual hand that played out was a weird poker hand, but not in a way that makes cheating likely. What’s the angle here? She was trying to cheat for the short stack and he failed to call the river with the strong bluff-catcher? She decided to cheat in favour of the big stack by giving the short stack two pair on a drawy board and hoping he could bluff the short stack? It doesn’t make any sense. Nor do any of the other hands from her downs at the FT ring any alarm bells.
I think there are two lessons from this snafu. The first is for the dealer and it’s one we can all use in our own lives. If you make a mistake, don’t proceed and hope no one notices. Pause, take your time and correct the mistake. In the long run, everyone will prefer that you did a good job slowly instead of doing a poor job quickly. The second is a lesson about the online information environment. If you see a clip of something that looks sketchy, such as poor dealing in a poker tournament, but do not see the hand that follows or any other evidence of something shady happening, it likely means that there is a reason the clip was cut off when it did— because nothing else shady happened. Don’t fall for the obvious bait; seek out more information and context before accusing someone of doing something bad.
Additional Sims For Premium Subscribers
Premium Subscribers are given access to a Google Drive folder where they will also be able to download the raw files of sims I used to write my POTDs, sims that are more accurate and appropriate than equivalent sims in the big public libraries. The past two weeks I uploaded
Postflop sims with three different squeeze calling ranges for POTD #355
A postflop sim with the exact sizing and stack to pot ratio for POTD #356
PIO ICM sims looking at my response vs a button 3x and 2x for POTD #357
Rocket Solver sims on the flop, turn and river for POTD #358
A PIO flop sim and a turn size test for POTD #359
Preflop sims looking at different sizings and postflop ICM sim for POTD #360
Rocket Solvers from on the flop, turn and river for POTD #361
PIO sims using custom HRC generated preflop ranges for POTD #362
Several preflop HRC sims and two PIO postflop ICM sims for POTD #363
Additional Analysis for Premium Subscribers
Everyday Premium Subscribers get an extra bit of analysis not included on Substack. Today, I’ll share #onemorething from POTD #361, where I wrote about the problems with not value betting the right size on the river.
POTD #361 #onemorething
A lot of times when I am playing or writing about a hand on POTD, I tend to think of value betting thresholds in position as a binary question: What’s my worst value bet here? Part of this is because in tournaments, the other part of that question, what size should I bet?, is dictated by our stack size, and the only size to bet is all in because you have ~pot to play and don’t need a smaller bet size. I just need to worry about the hand that is just strong enough to shove.
In this hand, the solver likes playing multiple river sizes, and that exposed several leaks in my strategy. My logic was normally pretty sound; when you check back twice IP, you often don’t bet a big size, because you can’t represent much more than thin value, so half pot is the right size to pick. In this hand I can bet as big as full pot with the Qh, and I can bet half pot with any QQ-AA, trips or straight combo. When I have KcTd I am trying to represent a hand like KhTd, which means I should bet full pot here. So I wasn’t value betting thin enough, and because of that I thought a hand that is a well above average value bet for me was a bottom of range value bet for me, which means I couldn’t pick a large size when it was best. From a results standpoint, full pot is mostly supposed to get the SB to fold QJ. I am not sure if I would have gotten that fold in game, but it would have been nice to put more pressure on hands like that.
Media
POTD subscriber, fan and Sunday Special submitter extraordinaire Michael Goodman has left his job as the Senior Soccer Editor at cbssports.com and is going full time into independent media. You should support his podcast, which I have guested on, The Double Pivot Podcast, and he will continue writing and editing with his podcast co-host, Michael Caley’s, over at their, Expecting Goals Substack. If you are a fan of soccer (or football) and this Substack. You should subscribe.
As always, I can be reached on

